Hypothetically, if someone were to give their card the "magic pencil" treatment (read: change their scores) what penalty do you think the club's committee should impose?
DQ?
Letter?
Suspension?
All of the above?
What are your thoughts?
The "Magic Pencil"
Hypothetically, if someone were to give their card the "magic pencil" treatment (read: change their scores) what penalty do you think the club's committee should impose?
DQ?
Letter?
Suspension?
All of the above?
What are your thoughts?
Your face looks like it caught fire and somebody tried to put it out with a fork.
DQ and letter for a first offence.
DQ for the first time then suspension if it occurs again.
How about a nice swift kick in the nuts!!?
Or DQ and first and last warning.
Agree with Eags. First warning then show them the door.
I had enough ingenuity to make the 1st post of 2010, and the decade.
Tales of woe - http://www.golflink.com.au/HandicapH..._no=2011701827
No warning, if proven show them the door!
No warning.. **** 'em off!
Countdown to Amateur Status |Golflink | Stats
WITB: Callaway FTi I-Mix 9.5º / King Cobra Old School 14º / King Cobra Old School 18º / Titleist 695MB 3I - PW / Titleist Vokey Raw 56º & 60º / Odyssey White Hot XG Teron 35" / Titleist ProV1x
What did you do Henno?
No warning.
Month ban first offence, then goneski if they reoffend.
Look if it is an adult who should know better, then yes I agree ban the prick.
What if we are talking about some 12-14 year old kid? That is a different story all together, you would warn them and hopefully they would learn their lesson and not re offend in the future.
Last edited by Eag's; 12th March 2010 at 05:14 PM.
Depends if they submit the card and then go home and post a thread about feeling guilty about it seeking opinions on whether they should admit to cheating or not.
Personally though, I reckon you should get one warning and be outed - usually then they would leave anyway
Moe Norman
Member of Ozgolf's Fastest Group
Mizuno MX500 8.5* | Cleveland Launcher 15* | Sonartec MD 19* | Sonartec MD 23* | Taylor Made 300 Forged 4-PW | Cleveland 588 53* Diadic RTG | Cleveland 588 57* RTG Nomad| Odyssey 2-Ball Blade
"I had played so poorly recently, I started thinking that maybe I should do something else. Then I saw my friends going to work every day and realised that my life wasn't so bad." -Steve Pate
Would have to be a very young kid as the 14-16 year old should know better. I don't think rules should be different for a 14yo or a 88yo.
It would probably depend on what evidence you had. If you can prove it is a deliberate cheating act as opposed to a seemingly innocent mistake, long suspension for the first offence and then ban them if it happens again.
Death by mechanical fisting (sans lube)
Agree with Eags.
But after the first offence, make them wear a white shirt with black writing "Im a cheating prick" on the front and back for their next 3 rounds.
And no, you cant wear anything over the top.
That is hilarious. I saw Jack had responded. My tip was staked out over an anthill...I was close!Originally Posted by Jack
I think a suspension is in order. Second offence bye bye.
Pieface, resident chopper, giant fweak. Lives in a pineapple under the seaFor posterity.
Hypothetically, who cheated?
I know the human being and fish can coexist peacefully
They should be sent to a week long scoring course with Blake
Miro.
Has to be a case by case basis, every situation is different, including the how the accused responds.
--
Criticism doesn't bother me, as it means I am doing something and people are watching.
The Only Truth the rest is all lies.
Henno, you're leaving Pacific??
____________________
WIT Callaway Forrester Cart Bag
Ping G10 9° driver / Nike VR Tour driver 9.5°
Ping G10 15.5° 3 wood
Ping G10 18° hybrid
Ping G10 21° hybrid
Titleist 755 irons 4 - pw
Vokey SM 53° wedge (bent from 54°)
Vokey SM 58° wedge
Mizuno Bettinardi BC1 putter / Nike Method 001
Bridgestone 330s / Nike One Tour
Is the question what should happen or what would happen ?
Piss em off!!! There is no room for blatant cheating in our game!!!
I intend to live forever. So far, so good.
What about discrete cheating??
____________________
WIT Callaway Forrester Cart Bag
Ping G10 9° driver / Nike VR Tour driver 9.5°
Ping G10 15.5° 3 wood
Ping G10 18° hybrid
Ping G10 21° hybrid
Titleist 755 irons 4 - pw
Vokey SM 53° wedge (bent from 54°)
Vokey SM 58° wedge
Mizuno Bettinardi BC1 putter / Nike Method 001
Bridgestone 330s / Nike One Tour
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
